Hey friends! If you follow me on Facebook or Instagram, you might have weighed in on how I should paint our fireplace. Well… big surprise, I went with black! Today I’m sharing our black painted fireplace.
Many of you liked the stone color and didn’t want me to paint it, but this room just had too many orange/brown tones. Between my camel recliner, the mid-century furniture that I love, the parquet floors, and the stone fireplace. Painting the fireplace would be an easy way to tone down all the browns.
Initially I was on the fence between black or white and I paid for a $5 gig on Fiverr to have someone mock it up both ways. If you’re like me and don’t know how to photoshop, this is a cheap way to see how your room will look. Here are the two mock-ups.
- Original
- White
- Black
You might remember I painted our brick fireplace black in our last house, and I used Amy Howard One Step Paint. I really liked how it covered in one thick coat so I decided to use it again! The entire fireplace took two quarts of the One Step Paint in Basic Black. **affiliate link**

Before I painted the fireplace, I used my vacuum attachment to clean all of the stone. It was crazy how dusty and dirty it was! Then I taped off each window panel and covered the hearth with paper to protect it.
The best part of this paint is that you can even use it on the surround! It can handle high heat and it adhered beautifully with no prep other than cleaning! I’ve learned that an old fat brush works best. I would load my brush to paint the grout lines first, and then do the faces of the bricks.
For Christmas my parents got us one of these work platforms and it was SO nice for the painting up high. I’ve already used it a ton.
At the end I used a small brush to edge the sides of the brick and where it met the ceiling. This took me about 8 hours of prepping, painting, and touching up. For the HUGE impact it made I’d say it was totally worth it.
Now that it’s done I love how the white skull pops against the black. I’m SO much happier with how this room looks now. It really toned down all the orange and brown tones and became a gorgeous accent. Lately it seems like I’m painting everything black, but it just seems to work!
I hope that this post inspired you to paint something that you hate! Even if it’s permanent, it’s worth it if you’ll enjoy it more! In case my fireplace isn’t enough to convince you, check out this roundup of other black painted fireplaces.




I was one that liked the original stone but I knew that you are the expert. And you are!! In your former fireplace I saw your vision. This fireplace took until the finished product. What a great way to explain how it toned down the many variations of brownish orange tones. I think rather than painting everything black you could easily say you are creating the perfect backdrop to make your furniture “stand out”! I thought you’d gotten a new media cabinet. Funny how the photo caused my eye to notice the onset of white more. The skull definitely shows more. I know we said tone down all the wood and yet the wood slice added makes so much sense. Even your drapes add dimension. You know how to remodel and restyle!! I love this facelift. I’m glad to know about the Amy Howard paint. I want to do my fireplace tile. Nice to know I can do my fireplace surround too.
You are so kind. Thank you for taking the time to tell me that! Sometimes I worry that readers are going to be really upset with my choices! YES I LOVE Amy Howard paint and would definitely recommend it. Have a wonderful day!
So glad you picked black! And I love that you included all three options for us to see. (Btw I just saw Emily Henderson promote your work – holy cow! Well done Jess!) xx
Hey thank you SO much! I was so excited when I saw my photo on her blog! So glad you saw it and thanks again for the congrats!
i hardly ever comment but this is freaking awesome, your whole room took on a totally different look love it xx
Thank you so much! I appreciate you taking the time to comment!
This kitchen is going to look so good! I am so excited to see the inspiration next week.
Thanks so much! I’m excited about yours. I wish I could embrace color like you! I’m so excited to see how you put all those amazing colors together!